Identifying potentially harmful language—including problematic or outdated Library of Congress Subject Headings—is one important step toward reparative metadata practices. However, deciding what to change and how to change it requires thoughtful judgment by metadata practitioners. This work calls for awareness, education, and sensitivity to the communities and histories represented in digital collections. The Inclusive Metadata Toolkit, created by the Digital Library Federation’s Cultural Assessment Working Group, offers valuable resources to support decision-making in reparative metadata work.